Meta description: Bill C-31 would let the CRA issue a notice of non-compliance carrying $50 a day to $25,000, and suspend the normal reassessment period while it stands.
Bill C-31 would give the CRA a new tool for audits that stall: the notice of non-compliance, carrying a penalty of $50 a day to a maximum of $25,000. The bill is at committee in the House of Commons and has not received Royal Assent, so none of this is law today. The part worth reading is not the penalty.
Where this stands
The measures originated in Budget 2024, appeared in draft legislation in August 2024 and again in revised form in August 2025, and were introduced as part of Bill C-31, the Budget 2025 Implementation Act, No. 2. First reading was May 6, 2026; second reading and referral to the Standing Committee on Finance followed on June 3, 2026. The bill remains in committee, with a Senate pre-study running alongside.
Everything below is therefore a proposal, drafted as introduced and capable of changing before it passes. The measures come into force on Royal Assent, with no transitional rule — which means that if they do pass, they will be capable of applying to audits already under way on that day.
One scope point worth stating plainly, because it is easy to assume otherwise: the notice of non-compliance regime and both penalties sit in the Income Tax Act. The GST/HST equivalent flagged in Budget 2024 has not been carried into this bill.
The notice of non-compliance
Proposed section 231.9 would let the Minister issue a notice of non-compliance to a person who has not complied, in full or in part, with a requirement under the information-gathering provisions. A $50 daily penalty accrues while the notice is outstanding, to a $25,000 maximum.
There is no de minimis threshold. The size of the file does not keep a taxpayer out of it, and the rules are not aimed at a particular kind of taxpayer — a corporation, an individual or a charity could each receive one.
No Federal Court order is needed first in the ordinary case. There is an exception that was added in this bill and did not appear in the earlier drafts: where the notice goes to a third party in respect of an unnamed-persons requirement, or concerns information about a person unrelated to that third party, the CRA would first have to obtain a compliance order.
A person served with a notice would have 90 days to ask the Minister to review it. The Minister would have 180 days to vary, vacate or confirm, failing which the notice is deemed vacated. The Minister would be required to vacate where it was unreasonable to issue the notice, or where the person had already done everything reasonably necessary to comply. A further 90 days would be available to apply to the Federal Court for judicial review.
No daily penalty would apply where the person reasonably believed the information was protected by solicitor-client privilege. That carve-out survived from the earlier drafts into the bill. So did the decision to drop the August 2025 proposal that would have let the CRA compel answers under oath.
The part that costs more than the money
Amendments to section 231.8 would suspend the normal reassessment period while a notice of non-compliance is outstanding, and while a person seeks judicial review of a domestic requirement or of the notice itself.
Three features of that suspension deserve attention.
It reaches non-arm's-length persons. A taxpayer's own reassessment period can stop running because a related corporation, shareholder or family trust has a notice outstanding in respect of information about the taxpayer — a party the taxpayer may not control.
It is not confined to the issue in dispute. Once the clock stops, it stops for the year, not just for the matter the information request concerned.
And winning does not rewind it. The period between filing a judicial review application and its final disposition would still extend the reassessment period, even where the court ultimately vacates the notice. A taxpayer who succeeds still loses time.
For a Canadian-controlled private corporation the normal reassessment period is three years. A single unanswered information request could hold a year open well past that.
The compliance-order penalty
Separately, proposed subsections 231.7(6) to (10) would add a penalty where the CRA obtains a Federal Court compliance order: 10% of the aggregate tax payable for each taxation year the order relates to. It is engaged only where tax owing for at least one covered year exceeds $50,000.
Earlier drafts framed this as "up to" 10%. The current drafting fixes the rate, while leaving the Minister discretion to impose a lesser penalty or none. Relief would no longer require the taxpayer to object first, and could extend to related interest.
The base is aggregate tax payable for the year, not the amount in dispute. A corporation with $1,000,000 of tax payable in a covered year could face a $100,000 penalty even if the audit ultimately produced no adjustment. For most owner-managed corporations this penalty is remote — it requires a court order and a year with more than $50,000 of tax owing — but it is worth knowing it exists.
A worked example
The following is a hypothetical illustration based on the bill as introduced.
A corporation receives an information request and disagrees with its scope. A notice of non-compliance is issued, and the corporation uses the full statutory process: 90 days to request a Ministerial review, 180 days for the Minister to decide, then 90 days to apply for judicial review.
That is 360 days of purely statutory steps before a Federal Court hearing is even scheduled. At $50 a day, the accrued penalty at that point is $18,000. The $25,000 cap is reached at 500 days — about 16 and a half months.
The more consequential number is the one with no dollar sign. Across those same 360-plus days, the reassessment period for the year in question has not been running. A three-year window has become something closer to four, and if the judicial review ends in the taxpayer's favour, the extension still stands.
What to do about it
Nothing in the bill changes what good practice already looks like. It changes what poor practice costs.
1. Treat the response date on a CRA letter as a real date. The CRA's current policy gives 30 days on a standard request, sends one written follow-up that does not grant additional days, and treats partial compliance as non-compliance.
2. Keep books and records complete, and keep the contact information on your CRA accounts current. A notice that goes to a stale address still accrues.
3. Where a request touches privileged material, get advice before responding. Both penalty carve-outs turn on a reasonable belief in solicitor-client privilege, and that belief is far easier to defend if the basis for it was documented at the time. There is no accountant-client privilege — a CPA cannot create that shelter.
4. If a request looks broader than the audit it belongs to, raise it early. Under these rules, disputing scope would carry a cost that has nothing to do with legal fees.
Let's talk
If you are in an audit now, or expect to be, the habits that matter are the ones you build before any letter arrives. If you would like to talk through how your records and response process would hold up, get in touch.
pashamc.ca